LordKaT.com LordKaT.com Forum LordKaT.com Wiki @LordKaT LordKaT on Facebook LordKaT on YouTube LordKaT Mafia Register | Login

10 posts / 0 new
Last post
Ginky
Ginky's picture
Offline
Joined: 04/26/2011
Comicu Feedback

Ginky here! Figured it would be a good idea to make a forum topic where people can give feedback/discuss the Comicu. Positive, Negative, whatever you want, it all helps improve the strip, it is for you guys after all :)

Side Note:
What i really should have explained at the start of Our War Game/Mafia forever is that the current arc, for me at least is to serve as a testing ground for what does and doesn't work in the strip. When i first started Comicu i had tons of suggestions from people about who should be in it (normally themself xD), what should happen, how it should play out etc etc. So the arc was made to try and cover as much of it as possible but still be enjoyable. It's coming to a close now and i have a pretty good idea of what did and didn't work, what needs to change etc. Just needed to get that out there, so if there's something you don't like, chances are it won't come up again :)

Have fun!

MrCrow
MrCrow's picture
Offline
Joined: 12/08/2011
moar birds :V On a serious

moar birds :V

On a serious note though. The main fault that comes to mind for me is that while it is awesome seeing all the characters some of them seem to have gotten lost and while those who have been shown are awesome and entertaining there are to many of them running around. What I can see working better are smaller arcs with different characters rather than one long one with a lot and then loosing many in the process.

Then again it is your project and you're free to do whatever you want and not listen to your friendly, neighbourhood crow :B

ZachDood
ZachDood's picture
Offline
Joined: 11/03/2011
Some of the more action-y Strips

I like Comicu first off. It's a really cool idea.

That being said I got lost during some of the more action-y strips. Like when Bubblefish got attacked in the giant bubblefish. I don't know if it was just me or what. But it felt really confusing.

CircleGuy
CircleGuy's picture
Offline
Joined: 10/25/2010
I think I can safely say

I think I can safely say everyone in the LKM loves the Comicu, but what you need is a guy, right, who's a Circle. Some sort of "CircleGuy" if you will :V

The only problem I had with the Comicu is that as MrCrow said above, I thought some of the characters got kinda lost in the whole thing. Also I thought the TF2 angle was dropped really quickly, with everyone siding with LK against Vogerl (except the new characters that debut'ed afterward).

Awesome stuff, Sir Gink :D

DementedDawn
DementedDawn's picture
Offline
Joined: 03/24/2011
:D

I think it's great so far, although I agree with Zachdood that it has gotten a little bit confusing during the action scenes. It's also sort of hard to tell who some of the new characters are sometimes, but most of them I get. *Joke about putting me in the comic* Just keep up the good work!

Stivvy
Stivvy's picture
Offline
Joined: 08/12/2010
Loving Comicu

Comicu is something I look forward to everyday, its the first thing I check when I come online, but thats not really feedback, so let's get to that.

First of all, the comedy style is great, it works and rolls smoothly. The series you did worked well, but the later episodes started going by really fast, the only focal point being the fight with Mr. Crow. The Bubblefish vs. Bubblebird fight, like the others have said, wasnt too focused and lead to confusing moments, even though the pay-off was marvelous.

Including some random moments from the livestream are always good, since it provides some inside jokes that are hilarious most of the time. The arc was a good idea, but also the random strips are golden, so it's really up to you and what kind of crazy ideas you have for Comicu.

Also, keep making awesome Comicu's, I'll be reading them every morning/afternoon/evening whenever I get the chance.

twistepuppet
twistepuppet's picture
Offline
Joined: 06/10/2011
Everyone else has already

Everyone else has already done a pretty good job of pointing out what didn't work all that well. So, I just want to tell you what I really liked about the strip so far. I like the inside jokes(fuck you sable! :P) and I like the transition to color. Well, color for the backgrounds. It makes the characters really stand out and the action is more distinct. I hope you stick with the color backgrounds.

Also, the one thing that I'm still confused about is that Nash is a toaster. And LK loves toasters... I'm not sure where I was going with this so just ignore this part. :P

achilles
achilles's picture
Offline
Joined: 10/03/2010
I love it

Great job as usual Ginky, though I think I have a better idea than that gumba character that I drew and that a groundhog would make sense do to me living near the place where they have Groundhog Day.

ChangeThief
ChangeThief's picture
Offline
Joined: 06/22/2011
I like It

I'm digging the comicu so far...That's all I have to say on the matter.

Chaos_Marine
Chaos_Marine's picture
Offline
Joined: 09/04/2010
I really like the art style

I really like the art style of Comicu which is delicious, particularly Behemothbear and the update where he attack Vogerl_Birdy for his hate remains the funniest one for me.

Login or register to post comments